Blog Post | February 13th, 2025
The Lavender Scare: America's Forgotten Witch Hunt
By Nicholas O'Connor
Embedded Files
PHOTO: SS Guardian
While America was hysterical with fear of communism in the 1950s, another, albeit lesser, panic seized the country: homosexuality. This was the era of the Lavender Scare, an official state purge of LGBTQ+ individuals, fueled by paranoia that they were security risks susceptible to communist blackmail. While the Red Scare and Senator Joseph McCarthy's communist witch hunt are known to most, the Lavender Scare trudged alongside, destroying thousands of lives and shaping the terrain of LGBTQ+ rights in America.
PHOTO: SS npr
The Origins of Fear
The Lavender Scare began in the early 1950s with the beginning of the Cold War, when national security was the be-all and end-all. Senator McCarthy in 1950 blamed communists and "sexual perverts" for infiltrating the State Department and labeled them a national security threat. It was felt that LGBTQ+ individuals were morally cunning and, therefore, vulnerable to blackmail by other nations. This unsubstantiated fear led to the signing of Executive Order 10450 by President Dwight D. Eisenhower in 1953, barring LGBTQ+ persons from working for the federal government or its contractors.
PHOTO: SS Guardian
The Human Cost
According to this directive, thousands of government employees were interrogated, investigated, and fired from work on mere suspicion of their sexual orientation. The interrogation process was invasive and humiliating, with the investigators asking very personal questions, tracking private lives, and even forcing people to identify others in exchange for mercy. Careers were destroyed, reputations were damaged, and livelihoods and social protection were lost by many. The shame and stigma were so intense that some victims took their own lives.
PHOTO: SS Court Anti
Impact and Legacy
The Lavender Scave did not just ruin lives—it institutionalized discrimination. It justified LGBTQ+ stereotypes as deviant and untrustworthy, embedding stigmas about the community that would not be shaken for decades. The effects of these policies lingered beyond the official prohibitions by years, informing government hiring policies and public opinion for generations.
But from this oppression came resistance. The Lavender Scare indirectly fueled the early LGBTQ+ rights movement. People like Frank Kameny, an astronomer who was fired from his government job because he was gay, became activists. Kameny challenged his firing in court and later co-founded the Mattachine Society of Washington, D.C., the first LGBTQ+ lobbying organization in the United States. He made the slogan "Gay is Good" popular, fighting for the dignity and equality of LGBTQ+ Americans.
PHOTO: SS Pride 202
Remembering and Learning
Even though its effect was profound, the Lavender Scare is often forgotten in mainstream histories. Its legacy serves as a reminder of how fear and prejudice can be employed against marginalized groups. Today, as we continue to struggle towards equality, remembering this ugly time is crucial. It serves as a reminder of the importance of defending civil rights and remembering how discrimination has been employed as an excuse in the name of national security.
The Lavender Scare wasn't just losing jobs—it was losing lives, communities, and identities. By keeping and sharing these stories, we honor the resilience of those who endured and resisted, allowing generations to come to live openly and honestly.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse